Thrasymachus

In passages 338b-342e Socrates engages in an argument with Thrasymachus about the explanation of exclusivelyice. Thrasymachus starting time defines justice as what is positive for the stronger. He supports this with numerous premises. The conventions atomic number 18 the strongest pigeonholing in all city. The moldrs be the people who lay down the laws. Each group restores laws that are discriminatory to themselves. The ruler decides what is just. It is just for the subjects to pursue the rulers. The subjects obey the just laws that the rulers create that are advantageous to the rulers. Therefore, justice is what is advantageous to the ruler, which is the stronger. Two other people are in the agency as well and they voice their opinion. succession Polemarchus agrees with Socrates conclusion, Clitophondoes non. Clitophon says that Socrates misunderstood Thrasymachus and that what he meant to say what that it is just to do what the ruler believes is advantageou s for him, the stronger. Thrasymachus says that this is non what he meant. The comment of a pay back is person who has the knowledge of medicine that he uses to help patients. The definition of an accountant is some bingle who has knowledge of mathematics that he uses to code finances. spell we know that all slynesssmen are people and make a mistake, thatis not why we call them craftsmen.

A journeyman is called that when he successfully uses knowledge of his craft to perform his craft, not when he fails to do so. When he fails to do so he is not employ the knowledge correctly and that conflicts with the true, base definition of w hat a craftsman is. A ruler’s craft is! vox populi over his subjects. Ruling correctly is ruling in what is in the advantage of the ruler. So, when a ruler does not rule correctly, or in his own advantage, he is not truly a ruler at that time. Socrates begins his re yettal by using one of Thrasymachus’ own examples. A doctor makes money and treats the sick, but he is called a doctor because he treats the sick. A transmit’s...If you destiny to get a full essay, order it on our website: BestEssayCheap.com

If you want to get a full essay, visit our page: cheap essay